"Max is a protagonist readers will root for and whose imaginary adventures they’ll enjoy." -- Kirkus Reviews

"Max is a complex yet relatable character, and Bates's gray-scale pencil-and-gouache artwork conveys plenty of emotion." -- Publishers Weekly

“Tolan’s vivid, clean writing is deceptively uncomplicated and the many issues touched upon are handled well. This book will resonate with kids while providing parents a great jumping-off point for conversations about how to overcome some of life’s obstacles.” -- School Library Journal

"Tolan creates a world rich with complex secondary characters, and Bates’s soft, realistic illustrations tie the story together and make it accessible to new readers and experienced readers alike." -- Horn Book